HELP! Need first dance song advice.?

Getting married June 7th, have been with my soon to be for 6 years, highschool sweethearts. We have had our ups and downs, and doubters, but here we are still together. A few ones we have listened too..."Livin our love song" - Jason Micheal Carol, "Dont know much" - Aaron Neville, "Your my angel" - Celion Dion/R. Kelly, "Keeper of the Stars" - Tracy Bryd, and many many more..however, nothing seems to appeal to both of us. Any other ideas??? I have searched the Top 500 Wedding song list, what did you use and why??? Thanks!